If you smell...
Saturday, July 18, 2009
Well, I have some ideas.
1) I can treat it very credulously. I wouldn't hide it from this blog at any stage....if they were really wise, they would do that kind of research before taking me at my word. I would effectively be lying only to them. Which still makes me a liar, but I think a greater good will be served, and I'd get some great footage from it (and I definitely would record it). I could easily concoct a huge elaborate story full of the vagaries that we all know to the point of tedium. I'm a good enough actor that I don't think I'd break character. If professional wrestling and taking 7 power-bombs to the head didn't make me break my concentration and character, I doubt this would.
2) I can treat it with faux-credulousness. That is, I can approach it like I was sort of curious, but was scientifically literate. A sort of weak-agnostic. I could approach it like I truly WANT to believe (which isn't untrue), but I know enough about the brain, cameras, energy, and electromagnetic fields to be able to stop them in their tracks at every turn. I could end their "investigation" with an air of relief. "Ah! I was so worried! I thought that all this shit would be going on....turns out it was all in my head, and I have a bit of a dust problem! Thanks so much for helping me realize how little there was to all this spooky-hocus pocus!"
3) I could treat it like a skeptic, who brings in these people purely because a loved one showed grave (ha!) concern, and I was doing it for their sake, not mine. Oh, sorry, she couldn't be here (my hypothetical wife). She's working right now. Poor thing was up all night last night and I love her so dearly that I feel I should do just about anything if it will ease her state of mind, even if I don't believe in it, and why the hell are you waving the EMF detector around like that? It's not a PK meter for god's sake!
I don't like to be a liar, but I hate this kind of stuff quite a bit too. I've always carried with me a bit of strange suburban envy of the people who live in big cities, and have access to this stuff on the constant. Peterborough has a culture of believers, but I don't think it's any larger, or more active than any other small, university town in Ontario. It's awfully average. Here, something is basically dropping in my lap, and I'm hesitating. All because I don't want to be a liar. But I still would love to do this. Suggestions?
Website Hit Counters
2 comments:
I agree with Surf. Now if the Sci-Fi channel Ghosthunters were romping around your town, I might be inclined to believe that it would serve a greater good to see those guys tripped up since SO many people buy into them.
But if they are willing to reach out to skeptics, you are providing them with a fabulous opportunity to do so. The Skeptologists pilot was something along those lines... a group of ghost hunters took a group of skeptics on a tour of a "haunted" ship. Man, I really hope that show gets picked up!

Ok, forget my gung-ho "do it" from the other post. That was rash and ill-advised, my bad. Upon reflection, I think, rather, you should express an interest in accompanying them to provide an alternative view point, and be up front about your skeptical bias. If they are for real, they can't fault you for that, and should embrace the challenge of having you along. Do not make of yourself a liar for the sake of a cheap trick. There is greater good to be gained by treating it seriously than by simply fucking with them. You too, as well as they, should keep an open mind. Channel Carl Sagan, and not Sacha Baron Cohen. Good luck, we're all counting on you.